BBC Newsnight Comments From Oxford Academic Prompts Labour MPs To Fight Back

He claimed there are 'no working class people as MPs any more'.
LOADINGERROR LOADING

Labour MPs have hit back after an academic claimed there are “no working class MPs any more”.

Speaking during a BBC Newsnight special on the Stoke-on-Trent by-election on Wednesday evening, University of Oxford professor Geoff Evans was asked about political alienation.

Evans, who grew up in Stoke, said that he blamed politicians for this, saying: “People have ignored, say, class divisions, they’ve pretended they either don’t matter any more.

“What’s actually changed is not the class divisions in our society, the inequalities, it’s what politicians offer.

Labour MPs took umbrage with Geoff Evans' comments
Labour MPs took umbrage with Geoff Evans' comments
BBC

“I do have to, to some degree, put the blame on Labour on this one, because in the 90s in particular they were so keen to appeal to an affluent middle class electoral base, they distanced themselves as much as they possibly could.

“Basically there are no working class people as MPs any more, the intake has almost disappeared.

“The rhetoric adopted by Labour, say by Blair, was very much chosen to be acceptable.”

A number of Labour MPs were quick to hit back at Evans, with Leicester South MP Jonathan Ashworth labelling his comments “patronising garbage”...

Good grief what patronising garbage https://t.co/BSfYqxUzZa

— Jonathan Ashworth MP (@JonAshworth) February 22, 2017

And me! https://t.co/ZJ7PIZOlJz

— Sharon Hodgson MP (@SharonHodgsonMP) February 23, 2017

@bbcnewsnight This really is nonsense. I challenge you to check out how many MPs have working class roots. There are quite a number. https://t.co/bFG4nEVwHd

— Barbara Keeley (@KeeleyMP) February 22, 2017

Guess people raised by single Mums in Tottenham don't count then. Not very many working class kids or professors at Oxford though are there? https://t.co/sSYNPqNyAz

— David Lammy (@DavidLammy) February 23, 2017

What a load of bollocks. https://t.co/tUjXmDoS2c

— Michael Dugher MP (@MichaelDugher) February 23, 2017

For such a clever man he is so wrong as plenty of MPs from working class backgrounds on Labour benches https://t.co/oqhSKvGUlz

— Diana Johnson (@DianaJohnsonMP) February 22, 2017

There are-I'm an MP of working class roots I represent constituency in which I was raised; there are many more inc @SharonHodgsonMP@KeeleyMP https://t.co/LuyzNANrtc

— Lyn Brown (@lynbrownmp) February 22, 2017

I tweeted about this too. He's wrong about working class MPs & wrong to suggest ALL politicians out of touch. This rubbish needs challenging https://t.co/EM57rzWosR

— R. Blackman-Woods (@robertabwMP) February 22, 2017

The claim also attracted criticism from a wider audience...

Also, the claim that there are no working class MPs is either a straight up lie, or he's too lazy/stupid to realise that there are.

— Josh Abey (@joshabey) February 23, 2017

Geoff Evans hasn't met many new Labour MPs I think lol. No "working class MPs" - yer arse. #Newsnight

— Jo Phillips (@joglasg) February 23, 2017

Hear, "Well there's no working class MPs cause you can't be WC *and* an MP" quite a lot. Without exception, it's from fairly posh people. https://t.co/CuBIvRZ8B1

— Sarah Kerton (@sarkerton) February 23, 2017

@LeaveEUOfficial

There are plenty of working class Labour MPs. Google it!

Completely spinning a false statement.

Don't believe lies.

— Sean (TreatMeGently) (@Treat_Me_Gently) February 22, 2017

But despite this, it seemed that some, including the Leave.EU campaign, agreed.

No working class of MP's any more!
I honestly think Prof Geoff Evans is absolutely right https://t.co/3RryfwNpWW

— Archie (@Peace_CDM) February 23, 2017

@BBCNewsnight too many career politicians, not enough community members

— Stella Morello (@StellaMorello) February 22, 2017

@BBCNewsnight he's not wrong, it's all career politicians these days... used to be doctors, lawyers, teachers etc...

— david mcgowan (@the_seraphim) February 22, 2017

Evans told The Huffington Post UK: “The data used in our new book, ‘The New Politics of Class’, shows there are now far fewer Labour MPs who had working class jobs before they entered parliament.

“The figure has fallen dramatically from around 40% in 1959 to less than 10% in 2015.

“Labour are not alone in this respect. MPs from mainstream UK political parties are overwhelmingly people who have no experience of having been in working class jobs. In this respect, the findings show Labour has become more similar to other mainstream parties.”

Labour has received some criticism for the make up of their membership base which increased massively in the wake of Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership victory.

Last year an internal analysis found a disproportionate number were “high-status city dwellers” pursuing well-paid jobs, not the working class voters traditionally represented by Labour.

In fact Labour is now the third most popular party amongst working class voters, behind Ukip and the Tories for what could be the first time in its history.

Close

What's Hot