'Line Of Duty' Theories: Fans Think They Know Who Balaclava Man Is After Thrilling Season 4 Episode 5

Can you crack the case before AC12 do?
LOADINGERROR LOADING

SPOILER ALERT! Do not read on if you have not watched the latest episode of ‘Line Of Duty’!

As ‘Line Of Duty’ reached its penultimate episode on Sunday (23 April), the net closed in on recent amputee DCI Roz Huntley, only for her to blow the case wide open again by getting her husband arrested for the murder of Tim Ifield.

But with 60 action-packed minutes still left to go, fans are speculating about what conclusion the series will reach, with theories floating about left, right and centre on who balaclava man is and what Roz’s link to him may be.

At the moment, the people of Twitter are overwhelmingly pointing the finger of blame at dodgy solicitor Jimmy Lakewell:

Great @Line_of_duty can't wait for the last episode. So many twists & evil people. I think Lakewell is Balaclava Man. Well done to all :-)

— Carwyn John (@CarwynCymro) April 24, 2017

@twin1nvasion @Line_of_duty I think it's the solicitor! When Steve got thrown doe the stairwell he was the only on other that Nick that knew he was there. Same build 2

— Mandy Sully (@147Sturls) April 23, 2017

@pauldunphy @sng60007 @Line_of_duty @madebylooby What do you think Paul? We think Balaclava Man is your one Jimmy Lakewell. Plus I am tres disappointed with Maneet.

— Jo Allen (@josusie) April 23, 2017

❤️😂 oh @Line_of_duty Balaclava man = lawyer Jimmy Lakewell obvs 'listen Ironside' - pure evil - & he knew Steve was on way 🕵️♀️#lineofduty https://t.co/HEcpYhxMxT

— Lesley Macniven (@lesleymacniven) April 23, 2017

Jimmy was the only other person besides Nick Huntley who knew about Steve Arnott’s arrival at Nick’s office. If Steve’s attacker was not Nick, could it have been Jimmy who was the balaclava-clad assailant who pushed him down the stairs? But even if he was Steve’s attacker, it doesn’t necessarily mean he is the same Balaclava Man who killed Leonie Collersdale and kidnapped Hannah Reznikova.

Jimmy Lakewell has drawn suspicion
Jimmy Lakewell has drawn suspicion
BBC

While AC12 believe it is possible Roz was covering up for her husband Nick, one fan claimed she could have been having an affair with Lakewell, and has been covering for his crimes:

@Line_of_duty I reckon I've cracked it it's the husbands solicitor because he's having an affair with Ross hunkly

— stephenleeguy (@lewy9) April 23, 2017

Any closeness to Jimmy would have given her access to knowledge about Michael Farmer, given he previously represented him during a sexual assault case. This would have enabled her to easily pin Jimmy’s crimes on him, and would explain why she is so determined to secure his conviction.

ACC Hilton’s shifty behaviour and determination to shut down AC12’s investigation into DCI Huntley continued to raise suspicions:

ACC Hilton #balaclavaman #LineofDuty well, I think he might be @Line_of_duty

— Jen Barber (@JenB116) April 23, 2017

I maintain my suspicions from last week, Hilton is balaclava man @Line_of_duty @Vicky_McClure @martin_compston @BBCOne

— Casey Muller (@caseyerturner) April 23, 2017

@mrdanwalker @BBCBreakfast @Line_of_duty I reckon Huntley is covering for the ACC said it the last 2 weeks. He's dodgy!

— Lynn Roberts (@Lynettaa) April 23, 2017

ACC Hilton is certainly not one to be trusted, and Matthew ‘Dot’ Cottan’s dying declaration from the end last series hinted at ring of corrupt officers. It could be that Hilton is ‘H’, who Cottan named, which would explain why he was so desperate to get his hands on the tape.

Could ACC Hilton be Balaclava Man?
Could ACC Hilton be Balaclava Man?
BBC

One fan believes that Lakewell and Hilton could be in on it together, with Hilton acting as a mole:

@missjesspess @Line_of_duty No me neither. Hilton is the mole and the solicitor is balaclava man. That's what I think anyway.

— Alex Hill (@asbo_flex) April 23, 2017

We know that he has already been giving Roz Huntley insider knowledge on AC12’s investigation and has also been getting PC Maneet Bindra to betray her team by supplying him with information. But has he also the missing link between Balaclava Man and Roz?

One interesting theory shared by a Daily Star journalist prior to the episode airing pointed the finger of blame at DS Neil Twyler - a member of Roz Huntley’s team who has largely gone unnoticed:

So here's my latest @Line_of_duty theory. Thoughts? Spot any holes? #LineofDuty pic.twitter.com/J2FZCgwdS5

— Ed Gleave (@EdHotTV) April 23, 2017

Given his increased presence in episode five, it is certainly a interesting take, but with DS Twyler providing information about Roz’s attempts to cover up the new forensic evidence from the recovery of Leonie Collersdale’s body, does this rule him out? Or is he simply trying to shift the focus of AC12’s investigation?

‘Line Of Duty’ concludes on Sunday at 9pm on BBC One. Catch up on the series so far on BBC iPlayer.

Close

What's Hot