Yesterday the Office for Fair Access announced that a total of £70m will be taken from students' pockets to fund the con trick of fee waivers. In response the National Union of Students has sent a letter to Deputy Prime Minister, Nick Clegg, calling on him to address our National Conference in his constituency town of Sheffield next year. The letter is co-signed by dozens of elected student officers and you can read it below:
Dear Mr Clegg,
You will no doubt remember that last year, days before the vote in the House of Commons to raise student fees to £9,000 per year, you said that a university would only be able to charge more than £6,000 per year in "exceptional circumstances". This turned out to be wrong, and too many universities wanted and were permitted to charge the upper limit.
You will also recall creating a £150 million National Scholarship Programme to help poor kids to into university. The net result of the changes in effect means that none of the £150 million National Scholarship Programme will end up in students' pockets; it will all be swallowed up in fee waivers or reductions in university bursaries. Our figures reveal that in fact some £13.8 million less in bursaries and scholarships will reach students' pockets in 2015 as a result of your changes.
As it dawned on the government that the costs of lending would be far too high, the rules of the game were changed, so that 20,000 places would be moved to institutions charging less than £7,500. Inevitably, the universities that have responded to this threat to their stability are those with the highest numbers of students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Far from striving to 'ensure fair access', this has resulted in a 'reverse pupil premium', where those universities that take on the most students from disadvantaged backgrounds are forced to spend less on their students as a result.
How have these universities managed to reduce their average tuition fee level? By diverting cash away from the pockets of students going to university next autumn, and instead to the Treasury - against the advice of your own access tzar, Simon Hughes. The reason that they have done so is simple - the government have not only permitted but incentivised this behaviour.
The release of data from the Office for Fair Access (OFFA) shows that the total being spent on bursaries by universities has dropped by a further £13.8 million (per year), which is in addition to the anticipated £55 million fall in bursaries by 2015/16 already announced in September.
Most frustrating of all is that you know that because a graduate will have their loan written off after 30 years, your own government has said that little more than 60% are likely to pay back their loan in full - and these will be those graduates who earn the highest salaries. This means that, other than for those higher earners, partial fee waivers are completely fictional; they never exist from the perspective of the graduate. Lower earners do not benefit by a single penny, but the Treasury gets to spend less on subsidising loans.
This means that partial fee waivers are nothing more than an accounting con trick: one that allows universities to keep a higher sticker price on their courses, enabling them to retain their 'top trump' score in the games of prestige, whilst at the same time reducing the burden on the Treasury.
We do not believe that these perverse results of the government's market system were intended, but they are the reality - and unless and until steps are taken to address these issues, students will continue to regard the government, and your party, with disdain.
You may know that next year, in our 90th year, our National Conference will be held in Sheffield. As a result, we would like to invite you to the conference next April to explain to delegates the decisions you have taken and to answer the many questions and concerns students across the country have.
I look forward to your reply.
Yours sincerely,
Liam Burns, President
National Union of Students
Jacob Kitchiner, President
Sheffield Hallam Students' Union
Thom Arnold, President
University of Sheffield Students' Union
Joe Vinson, President
Cornwall College Students' Union
David Howells, President
University of Bath Students' Union
Rob Scully, President
City University London Students' Union
Thomas Hollick, President
City College Norwich Students' Union
David Cichon, President
University of Sussex Students' Union
Terry Preston, President
Brighton Student' Union
Sam Grayson, AU President
St Marys University College Twickenham
Reni Eddo-Lodge, President
University of Central Lancashire Students' Union
Colin Offler, President
University of the West of England Students' Union
Karl Hobley, President
Reading University Students' Union
James Haywood, President
Goldsmiths Students' Union
Caroline Dangerfield, President
University of Salford Students' Union
Liam Davis, President
De Montfort Students' Union
Aidan Mersh, President
Hull University Union
Jonathan Wright, President (Education & Engagement)
University Campus Suffolk Union
Sean Ruston, Aldwych Group Chair and Warwick SU Education Officer
Oliver Deed, Chair
University of Surrey Students' Union
Sam Lewis, President
Worcester Students' Union
Paul Mason, President
Oxford Brookes Students' Union
Rebecca Bridger, President
Loughborough University Students' Union
Matte Andrews, President
Glasgow Caledonian University Students' Association
Leigh Hankinson, President
York St John Students' Union
Oeiisha Williams, Education and Welfare Officer
Birmingham City Students' Union
Matt McPherson, President
Edinburgh University Students' Association
Rosie O'Neill, Welfare & Rights Officer
Cambridge University Students' Union & Graduate Union
Alex Causton-Ronaldson, Chair of the Trustee Board
University of the Creative Arts Students' Union
Jason Smith, Student Council Chair
University of Central Lancashire Students' Union, Preston campus
Ben Jackson, Education Officer
Leeds University Union
Luke Frost, Chair of the Executive Committee
University of the Creative Arts Students' Union
Emma Meehan, Vice President Societies and Activities
Edinburgh University Students' Association
Ellis Jones, Vice President, Academic Experience
Oxford Brookes Students' Union
Tash Ross, Community and Student Rights Officer
Union of University of East Anglia Students
Mat Denton, Welfare Officer
University of Sheffield Students' Union
Philippa Faulkner, Vice President Services
Edinburgh University Students' Association
Godfrey Atuahene Junior, Vice President (Education and Democracy)
University of Portsmouth Students' Union
Mike Williamson, Vice President Academic Affairs
Edinburgh University Students' Association
Dean Smith
University of the Creative Arts Students' Union
Ben Cronin, Welfare Officer
City College Norwich Students' Union
Naomi McKay, Vice President
Wakefield College Students' Union
Mark Sewards, Communications and Internal Affairs Officer
Leeds University Union
Craig Best, Vice President Academic Representation
Union of Brunel Students
Emma Baker, Publicity Officer and Vice President-elect
Bridgwater College Student Union
Josee Tisdale, Further Education Officer
City College Norwich Students Union
Sam Higham, Vice President (Education)
Keele University Students' Union
Phil Pocknee, Vice President (Welfare)
Hull University Union
Izzy John, Welfare Officer
University of Warwick Students' Union
Clare Keogh, Women's Officer
Kingston University Students' Union
Rachel Wenstone
NUS Anti Racism Anti Facism Co-Chair
Kanja Sesay
NUS Anti Racism Anti Facism Co-Chair
Fiona Wood, Mature Students Representative
NUS National Executive Council
Chloe Parkin
Chester University Students' Union
Ivan Nicholls
Newcastle University Students' Union
Ben Fisher, Community Officer
Leeds University Union
Pat Plested, Canterbury Campus Officer
University of the Creative Arts Students' Union