BBC Question Time: Ayesha Hazarika Shuts Down 'Bully' During Fierce Defence Of Angela Merkel

Political adviser and comedian also takes on 'crazy man-babies'.

BBC’s Question Time was arguably more confrontational than ever this week against a backdrop of Jeremy Corbyn’s triumphant Labour Party conference, ongoing Brexit tension and the rise of the far-right in Germany.

The first exchange was over Corbyn’s Labour Party being poised to sweep to power, with one Wolverhampton audience member warning its move to the left would “take us back into the early 1900s” and, in turn, another talking of the “pride” that had returned to the party.

It was too much for many even at that stage.

Very shouty #bbcqt

— Chris Bryant (@RhonddaBryant) September 28, 2017

Well that is *more* than enough for me. Horrific. #bbcqt

— Tom Peck (@tompeck) September 28, 2017

But things got even more heated.

On the panel was Ayesha Hazarika, a former Labour Party adviser, columnist and stand-up comedian, who essayed the Alternative for Germany (AfD) party that took 13 per cent of the vote in Sunday’s elections in Germany.

She described them as “essentially a racist, Nazi party” when she began to be heckled by a man in the audience.

“They are,” she responded, adding the party “made a big step forward, a big goose-step forward at this election”.

Ayesha Hazarika.
Ayesha Hazarika.
BBC

“They said that actually World War Two was fine and the German army did a really good job,” Hazarika continued through the jibes of “prove it” and “you’re a liar”.

“I’m sorry, they are a racist party. But the point is, Angela Merkel is a pragmatic politician and I think she’s a politician with humanity.”

At this point, the man in the audience contended Merkel is “a communist, an Eastern European communist”, and suggested she has “got the uniform”. To be clear, the East German-born Chancellor leads the centre-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU).

"She's a communist, an East a European communist." The AFD supporter in the audience was talking about Angela Merkel. #bbcqt pic.twitter.com/LHbRO6jGDO

— Frederic Moreau (@goodclimate) September 28, 2017

“She’s actually not a communist. I’ll tell you something, she has got values and she’s got pragmatism,” came Hazarika’s calm riposte.

When the audience member signalled he thought Hazarika was an “idiot”, he became too much to indulge any longer.

“Actually, you are a bully because you won’t let anyone else talk, all right,” said the panelist, prompting a huge wave of applause. “Are you just going to keep shouting at me? You let me speak, I’ll let you speak.”

Hazarika continued her point, and launched into a withering attack on world leaders:

“In a world full of demented men like Kim Jong Un, Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin - these crazy man-babies - I’m very glad that Angela Merkel is there. In terms of global leadership, she is a moral authority in a very scary world right now.”

The exchange drew criticism from Labour MPs angered by David Dimbleby’s non-intervention.

Just got in. Switched on TV. It's #bbcqt. Well done @ayeshahazarika dealing w bully in audience. Pathetic Dimbleby chairing. Switching off

— Yvette Cooper (@YvetteCooperMP) September 28, 2017

Crying out for the chair to take control; why is David Dimbleby allowing this rude man to continuously heckle @ayeshahazarika? #bbcqt

— Liz McInnes (@LizMcInnes_MP) September 28, 2017

Others were of a similar mind, praising Hazarika and damning the show.

Good for you @ayeshahazarika - he, quite rightly, came out of that looking like an idiot https://t.co/5gWO9ooeLb

— Beth Rigby (@BethRigby) September 28, 2017

Well said @ayeshahazarika calling out that idiot bully in the #bbcqt audience. Dimbleby should've chaired better though.

— Sarah Hayward (@Sarah_Hayward) September 28, 2017

#bbcqt Well done @ayeshahazarika for facing down loudmouthed bully in audience and for correctly characterising #AfD as a fascist party.

— Liz Clements (@LizClements) September 28, 2017

#bbcqt This is the worst edition for years. Loudmouthed bullies in the audience trying to shout women down but thankfully not achieving.

— (((Paul Sandars))) (@PaulSandars) September 28, 2017

She later tweeted her first appearance on the show was “quite the experience”.

Thanks so much for all your supportive comments about my debut on #BBCQT & to the show for having me on. Was quite the experience!

— Ayesha Hazarika (@ayeshahazarika) September 28, 2017

The panel included Conservative minister Karen Bradley, Labour chairman Ian Lavery, writer Peter Hitchens, and Brexit supporter Richard Tice.

Looking forward to seeing @IanLaveryMP on #BBCQT tonight. pic.twitter.com/RKNop92Mec

— Jeremy Corbyn for PM (@JeremyCorbyn4PM) September 28, 2017
Close

What's Hot