BBC Question Time Brexiteer's 'Ballot Paper' Monologue Speaks To Heart Of Debate On Vote

There was no question two on the ballot paper.
LOADINGERROR LOADING

A member of the BBC Question Time audience accused Nicky Morgan and fellow Tory rebels of a “really treacherous act” for voting against the Government yesterday, saying there was no “question two” on the referendum ballot paper.

He began with a rousing speech in which he said Barnsley voted overwhelmingly Leave (68%) to stop immigration that “damaged the working class communities that this town is”, a bold statement when according to the latest Census data only around 4% of the town’s population are non UK-born, far below the national average of 11.5%.

Massive immigration problem in Barnsley. I feel for the fella... pic.twitter.com/HCIG6P45uK

— Kick Arse (@kickarseHD) December 15, 2017

(Detailed figures can be viewed here and here)

He added: “We made our decision and we knew why we made it.

“And I know you say we’re thick up North but I remember voting on my ballot paper and it said ‘Leave or Remain’.

“And it didn’t say when I put my [vote] in Leave: ‘Now turn to question two - do you want the soft Brexit or the hard Brexit?’”

His speech won him a round of applause from the audience, but divided others on social media.

Martin Lewis, founder of Money Saving Expert, said:

No it didn't have a second question saying "do you want a soft brexit or hard brexit", nor ask views on immigration, single market and more. That's the problem!

We had a black and white vote on a rainbow of issues. It has been devastating, divisive and directionless. #bbcqt

— Martin Lewis (@MartinSLewis) December 14, 2017

Leave.EU decided the audience member ‘won the debate’.

WATCH | This gentleman just won @BBCQuestionTime. #BBCQT pic.twitter.com/86PeN27mBv

— LEAVE.EU 🇬🇧 (@LeaveEUOfficial) December 14, 2017

But others took issue with the idea that the notion of a hard or soft Brexit was never implicit when people went to the polls last year.

He didn't though, did he. Stated that ref question didn't ask which type of Brexit people wanted, but failed to understand the obvious implication - that we need to have a national debate and not be railroaded in to a hard damaging version.

— Richard Bentall #FBPE (@RichardBentall) December 14, 2017

It was not clear - this article was on the BBC website in the run-up to the vote and said ‘Leave EU and stay in single market’ https://t.co/wqj99EWsNr

— Change Britannia! (@ChangeBritannia) December 15, 2017

The Question Time gentleman also lashed out at “these elite politicians”, echoing a sentiment voiced recently by Nigel Farage, arguably the most influential voice of the Leave campaign.

My contempt for career politicians knows no bounds.

— Nigel Farage (@Nigel_Farage) December 13, 2017

Good to see seven time by-election and general election candidate Nigel Farage MEP sticking it to the career politicians...

— (((Dan Hodges))) (@DPJHodges) December 13, 2017

.@MattChorley nails it: pic.twitter.com/wyRQ06XYSG

— Alex Clifford (@alexmarkcliff) December 14, 2017
Close

What's Hot