'Death In Paradise's New Detective Ardal O'Hanlon Has Mixed Response After A Seamless Tropical Transition

Plus ca change... but not much.

‘Death in Paradise’ marked a new era last night, with its third home-grown detective taking up residence in the beach shack and setting about solving the disproportionate amount of violent crime on the tropical island of Saint Marie.

DI Jack Mooney, whom we first met two episodes ago in the London-based double bill, played by Irish actor Ardal O’Hanlon, had barely put his suitcases down before a years-old murder of a local newspaper editor had to be reopened.

Humphrey may have gone, but everything else stayed the same, as Jack set about interviewing the suspects one by one, looking puzzled at the whiteboard, sipping some rum at Katherine’s Bar, and finally having a Columbo moment, before assembling everyone in the last 13 minutes.

DI Jack Mooney (Ardal O'Hanlon) is the new detective in town, having replaced Humphrey Goodman on the island of Saint Marie
DI Jack Mooney (Ardal O'Hanlon) is the new detective in town, having replaced Humphrey Goodman on the island of Saint Marie
BBC

Despite the similarities to every previous episode ever, not every fan was happy with the change of faces - it seems several are still missing the bumbling Humphry…

Did Kris Marshall take the writers with him when he left #DeathInParadise? Mooney's dialogue is terrible. This is painful.

— Trek779 (@Trek779) February 17, 2017

Oh dear #deathinparadise Ardal has all the personality of a shallot.🤣

— Rob (@Plantagenet2) February 17, 2017

I don't like the new inspector #deathinparadise please bring back Humphrey 😭😭

— Chey Kingston ✨ (@chey_kingston) February 16, 2017

I still enjoyed the mystery on #deathinparadise and @ardalsfolly was very good. But I miss Humphrey's quirky cuteness... @deathinparadise

— Natalie F (@natalARTte) February 16, 2017

However, Ardal had plenty of his own fans ready to welcome to the island...

I love Ardal O'Hanlon in #deathinparadise 😁😎👌🏻☀️🌴his accent is lush!

— Are ya ready kids? (@ayeayecapta1n) February 16, 2017

Have to say @ardalsfolly seems to have fit right in on #deathinparadise I've warmed to his character quicker than I did to Humphrey

— Michelle Murphy (@mich_m78) February 16, 2017

Thought it may not work but #deathinparadise still brilliant

— STEVE WILLIAMS (@JarheadSteve) February 16, 2017

Man, Humph was great and all, but this Irish man got skillz. #deathinparadise #DeathInParadise pic.twitter.com/XtmE8OgQdG

— Chris McGeorge (@crmcgeorge) February 16, 2017

For some, mere change is always good...

The changing of the Inspector in #deathinparadise is now more exciting that the regeneration of the Doctor in #DrWho

— HRH Teddy Windsor (@BigTeddyWindsor) February 16, 2017

While one had a novel idea for getting the best of both worlds...

What we need now is a spin off. Humphrey solving crimes in London and going home to Martha every night. #deathinparadise

— Gemma (@Gemma_235) February 9, 2017

Kris Marshall departed the show in the previous episode, with his character Humphrey opting to stay in London with his love Martha. It was, similarly, Kris Marshall’s big heart that moved him to quit the show after four series, saying it was too difficult to be apart from his family, during the six months the show is filmed in the Caribbean.

Catch up with ‘Death in Paradise’ on BBCiPlayer.

Close

What's Hot