Great British Bake Off Fans Had Some Very Strong Reactions To The Bakers' Definition Of A Cornish Pasty

Pasty purists were not happy.
LOADINGERROR LOADING

Warning! This article contains spoilers about the latest episode of The Great British Bake Off.

There are some foods you just do not mess with, and it became apparent the Cornish pasty was one of them after Tuesday’s episode of The Great British Bake Off.

Fans of the Channel 4 baking competition had some pretty strong reactions to the contestants’ interpretations of the classic baked treat, as they put their own twists on it.

This week’s Signature Challenge saw judges Prue Leith and Paul Hollywood ask the eight remaining bakers to cook up six Cornish pasties as part of Pastry Week.

It saw them produce a mixture of creations, that strayed pretty far from the traditional recipe of beef, potato, swede and onion, wrapped in a neatly D-shaped shortcrust pastry complete with crimps to make a crust.

Among the goods the bakers produced claiming to be pasties included a fish-shaped and fish-flavoured version, one with a toad-in-the-hole theme, and one that was shaped like a samosa.

There’s the tiniest possibility that Linda’s pasties designed to look very much like samosas are, in actual fact, samosas. #GBBO pic.twitter.com/08PqoEGqqF

— British Bake Off (@BritishBakeOff) October 20, 2020

Pasty purists were not happy at the deviation, with plenty of conversation about it on Twitter...

Watching all these Cornish pasty reinterpretations #GBBO pic.twitter.com/STqtOXOVyo

— Alex Davis (@Alex_Loze_Davis) October 20, 2020

GBBO: Make a Cornish pasty.. but use any filling you want

Cornish people: pic.twitter.com/O4RAbJ0BiQ

— Cathy💭 (@cathy_parkin) October 20, 2020

As a Cornish person I can safely tell you that not one of those is an actual fucking pasty. #gbbo

— Jen Faulkner (@jfaulknerwriter) October 20, 2020

A fish pasty #GBBO pic.twitter.com/tiU278r0m4

— David Brisbane (@DavidB1996) October 20, 2020

I’m a Bake Off lover but I’m also a Cornishman. A pasty is a pasty & doesn’t need any messing with! #GBBO pic.twitter.com/Suqor1RhuX

— Dom Jones (@HantsPoliceChap) October 20, 2020

Cornish Pasty circa 2020 #GBBO pic.twitter.com/9bKMgj8zfs

— Conor Noon (@Conor_Noon) October 20, 2020

People from Cornwall are going to die watching the bakers put coconut flakes in a pasty #GBBO #gbbo2020

— Sam Damerell (@SamDamerell1) October 20, 2020

When someone puts fish in a pasty #gbbo pic.twitter.com/Cj1fwo6Gw5

— Rachael (@RachaelvsWorld) October 20, 2020

The Cornish right now seeing a samosa masquerading as a pasty. #GBBO #pastygate pic.twitter.com/HIPea88k3y

— Mark Binmore (@MarkBinmore) October 20, 2020

Still waiting for the bakers to produce a Cornish Pasty #GBBO pic.twitter.com/5aZRS5XxAQ

— Daniel Smith (@Doctor_63) October 20, 2020

What are you doing to the pasty? #GBBO #BakeOff #cornishpasty pic.twitter.com/jpBVSBPGY2

— Anna-Marie Morozow (@amm91mma) October 20, 2020

EVEN THE CORNISH BLOKE DIDNT MAKE A CORNISH PASTY #GBBO pic.twitter.com/TIasWJu5mF

— Megan Hunt (@MegHunt_) October 20, 2020

They are NOT Cornish Pasty’s.
Shocking efforts.
Now this is a Cornish Pasty by a Cornish maid feat. beef skirt, potatoes, turnip, onion, butter, salt and loads of white pepper. That’s how it’s done!! #gbbo pic.twitter.com/KvxJaPuzwj

— Charlotte Hodges (@Char_Hodges_) October 20, 2020

all these bakers putting fish in a pasty should immediately be eliminated #GBBO

— Amy Goodall (@amieexgoodall) October 20, 2020

Elsewhere in Pastry Week, the bakers were tasked with making eclairs for the Technical Challenge, finishing things off with a caged tart in the Showstopper.

Laura was named Star Baker after impressing Paul and Prue in all three rounds, while it was Linda who found herself eliminated after a series of blunders.

She had produced the samosa-shaped pasties, placed last in the Technical, while her cage fell apart as she tried to make a Gypsy Tart.

Next week, the seven remaining bakers will take part in Bake Off’s first ever Japanese Week.

The Great British Bake Off continues next Tuesday at 8pm on Channel 4.

Close

What's Hot