Scottish Independence Comedy Sketch's Ruth Davidson Imitation Sparks 'Homophobia' Row

'It seems we must now apologise for no longer finding "dyke" offensive.'

Two of Scotland’s most senior politicians have been embroiled in a row over a contentious comedy sketch that was branded “homophobic”.

SNP MP Joanna Cherry sparked criticism for her comments on the performance at a pro-independence event, which saw the Scottish Tories leader mocked for her sexuality.

The satirical “rap-off” was held at the annual Scottish Independence Convention, a cross-party forum for anti-Union campaigners. It saw members of the group ‘Whitsherface’ imitate Davidson, Nicola Sturgeon, Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale and SNP MP Mhairi Black.

In it, openly-gay Davidson was referred to as “Ruth Dykey D”, while the performer pretending to be her made a number of heavily sexualised comments about Black.

The performer playing Black (far right) looked visibly disgusted at the Davidson character's sexual quips about her
The performer playing Black (far right) looked visibly disgusted at the Davidson character's sexual quips about her

The skit was praised by Cherry as being “hilariously irreverent satire”. But when video of it was published online, Davidson’s party fired back.

“The nationalists are always the first to scream offence at anything that even mildly upsets them,” a spokesperson for the Scottish Conservatives told the Scotsman.

“But when it’s a joke at the expense of pro-UK campaigners, it’s suddenly harmless and hilarious.

“The SNP should be lambasting this, but instead its elected representatives are praising it on social media.”

Davidson got engaged to her long-term partner Jen Wilson (left) in May
Davidson got engaged to her long-term partner Jen Wilson (left) in May
Andrew Milligan/PA Wire

Stonewall Scotland’s director also warned that the term dyke was “homophobic” and said if its use went unchallenged it gave “the green light for others to follow suit”.

Cherry, who is openly gay, hit back in light of the critics, saying she was not offended by the performance and reiterated her condemnation of homophobia.

For all those mansplaining what homophobia is don't bother I'm gay & have been on receiving end regularly on Twitter but heard none today

— Joanna Cherry QC MP (@joannaccherry) September 18, 2016

It's a shame if anyone was offended today. I wasn't but as an out lesbian & long term supporter of #LGBT rights I obvs condemn homophobia

— Joanna Cherry QC MP (@joannaccherry) September 18, 2016

For many years lesbians have self referenced as dykes now it seems we must apologise to others for no longer finding the word offensive. Lol

— Joanna Cherry QC MP (@joannaccherry) September 18, 2016

But her colleague in the SNP, Stewart McDonald, who worked on the LGBT campaign for independence back in 2014, admitted the mockery of Davidson was “just not okay”.

I worked on the @Yes_LGBT campaign with lots of great people and this kinda stuff does not help. Just not okay. https://t.co/4cmU3tVh2s

— Stewart McDonald MP (@StewartMcDonald) September 18, 2016

He added:

That said, I'm amazed at some of those who have all of a sudden woken up to homophobia on Twitter https://t.co/3fvNkcUdt0

— Stewart McDonald MP (@StewartMcDonald) September 18, 2016

The row divided people on social media, with many people not taken by Cherry’s defence.

Ok
Thought experiment: I call a gay patient a dyke in clinic tomorrow. How would Joanna Cherry QC defend me at the GMC?
Bantz?
Joke?
Satire?

— Dr Cromarty (@drcromarty) September 18, 2016

If Joanna Cherry has been on the receiving end of homophobia she'll know how hurtful it is. So why laugh at Ruth being subjected to it?

— Kirst ∞ (@Kirsten93_) September 18, 2016

So, just to be clear, is it not homophobia because it wasn't about Joanna Cherry? 🤔

— Ali Harper (@ali_harper) September 18, 2016

While others were less upset, saying the sketch was “dimwitted” but not offensive.

@Gedk @jsteve372 @joannaccherry @RuthDavidsonMSP What was homophobic? Use of the word dyke? Really?

— C J Robertson (@CJR0bertson) September 18, 2016

@Maureen56596209 @joannaccherry @Gedk @RuthDavidsonMSP @ScotConvention It was stupid. Dimwitted. That's about the extent of it.

— J. R. Tomlin (@JRTomlinAuthor) September 18, 2016

NOW READ:

Close

What's Hot