The Goldfinch Reviews: Critics Pull Precisely Zero Punches As Film Debuts At Toronto Film Festival

The big-screen adaptation of Donna Tartt's novel has not gone down as well with critics as many were anticipating.
LOADINGERROR LOADING

It might have been one of the year’s most anticipated films, but critics have not pulled any punches when it comes to the big-screen adaptation of The Goldfinch.

The Goldfinch – based on the Pulitzer-winning novel by Donna Tartt – is something film fans have been looking forward to ever since it was announced, not just because of the critical acclaim the novel received, but also because of its impressive all-star cast, which includes Nicole Kidman, Ansel Elgort, Sarah Paulson and Stranger ThingsFinn Wolfhard.

However, after receiving its debut at the Toronto International Film Festival over the weekend, critics have begun sharing their initial reviews on Twitter, and calling the film divisive would be putting it generously.

Nicole Kidman and Ansel Elgort in The Goldfinch
Nicole Kidman and Ansel Elgort in The Goldfinch
Warner Bros

Among critics’ biggest qualms is the film’s length (which shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise to anyone who has actually read the book), while it’s also been branded “deathly dull”, “shockingly bad” and even a “disaster”.

It’s not all bad news, though, with some singling out how well the film is shot, as well as praising performances from Nicole Kidman, Ansel Elgort and Finn Wolfhard.

Here’s a selection of what has been said so far…

THE GOLDFINCH is one of the worst movies I’ve seen all year. It’s shockingly bad. https://t.co/VJdD9rLDP1

— Matt Goldberg (@MattGoldberg) September 9, 2019

Ugh. THE GOLDFINCH was so bland and boring, I just. I really can't say much other than nothing happens for almost 2 hrs, then everything happens at once but it's so disconnected that it evokes no feeling. #TIFF19

— Yolanda Machado (@SassyMamainLA) September 9, 2019

THE GOLDFINCH: Gorgeous and airless. The actors all do what they can, and some — Finn Wolfhard, Sarah Paulson — manage to shake the film out of its chilly self-consciousness. Nothing, though, can rescue the absurdly rushed and busy final act. #TIFF19

— Adam B. Vary @ TIFF (@adambvary) September 9, 2019

THE GOLDFINCH: A movie as inert as the oil painting it is titled for. John Crowley's listless direction and a cast apparently afflicted with narcolepsy make this the first big bomb of #TIFF19 Some books were never meant to be movies. pic.twitter.com/3ZCfDtyuky

— Peter Howell (@peterhowellfilm) September 9, 2019

Just saw The Goldfinch, and as a fan of the book, I’m so disappointed. But also, I guess it’s a testament to the power of literature. Some things just can’t or won’t translate to the screen.

— Britt Julious (@britticisms) September 9, 2019

The embargo's up on THE GOLDFINCH, a handsome, earnest and deathly dull adaptation of Donna Tartt's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel. #TIFF19 https://t.co/odfgDvZPy9

— Glenn Sumi (@glennsumi) September 9, 2019

Based solely on the evidence presented in the movie version, I'd have to guess that the novel THE GOLDFINCH, which I have not read, must be the silliest Pulitzer-winner ever.

— Bob Mondello (@Bob_Mondello) September 9, 2019

I saw The Goldfinch last night. I liked the actors and the performances but it was definitely 20 minutes too long. It was slow until near the end and then so much happened it was confusing. At least to me. #TheGoldfinch

— Alana Stewart (@AlanaKStewart) September 9, 2019

THE GOLDFINCH: The longest movie of the year. Don’t fact check that. Just trust me.

— Brian Tallerico (@Brian_Tallerico) September 9, 2019

I’m afraid THE GOLDFINCH isn’t very good. As usual these days, too faithful to a text that needed more ruthless rearranging. It looks nice enough, I guess. #TIFF19 pic.twitter.com/2XpyX7C458

— 🥃Donald Clarke📽 (@DonaldClarke63) September 9, 2019

Yikes. I emerged from THE GOLDFINCH, wondering if I was maybe being a bit harsh in my own head. Looks as if I hated it about 25 percent less than the current hatred mean. A future candidate for @Had_Oscar_Buzz, I suspect. #TIFF19

— 🥃Donald Clarke📽 (@DonaldClarke63) September 9, 2019

I really liked the movie for everyone asking! Yes - it’s long, I think 20 minutes or so could have been cut out. But overall it’s a good movie and I loved every performance. Finn Wolfhard is amazing too! Loved his accent. #TheGoldfinch

— Lauren Veneziani (@DCfilmgirl) September 9, 2019

Really enjoyed watching the story unfold in #TheGoldfinch. @AnselElgort gives a beautiful performance and Nicole Kidman is as lovely as ever. Roger Deakins cinematography is stunning!!!! And Sarah Paulson is amazing!! Loved her role. @MsSarahPaulson #TIFF19 pic.twitter.com/IE8qpzOLHp

— Lauren Veneziani (@DCfilmgirl) September 9, 2019

It was maybe a very brave mistake to try to make a movie out of a novel like #TheGoldfinch but not an uninteresting one, I sort of fell for it anyway #TIFF2019

— Leah Greenblatt (@Leahbats) September 9, 2019

Deakins continues to amaze me. John Crowley told me an amazing story about this shot from #TheGoldfinch. Deakins took a sweater & shook it resulting in the dust you see falling in this shot from the trailer. Great performances especially from Wright, Cummings & Elgort. #TIFF2019 pic.twitter.com/yTJdLjKmdH

— Kevin McCarthy (@KevinMcCarthyTV) September 9, 2019

Upon its release in 2013, the novel version of The Goldfinch topped the US bestsellers list for more than 30 weeks, similarly reaching the number one spot in the Sunday Times’ bestsellers list in the UK.

Aside from the aforementioned actors, the film also stars Aneurin Barnard, Luke Wilson, Jeffrey Wright and Denis O’Hare.

The Goldfinch will hit cinemas in the UK on 27 September.

Close

What's Hot