The Masked Singer: Most Popular Fan Theories And Rumours About This Year's Stars

Fans reckon they've already worked out the identities of Jellyfish, Knitting and Otter.
The Masked Singer has got the whole nation guessing once again
The Masked Singer has got the whole nation guessing once again
ITV/Shutterstock/Ken McKay/Steve Meddle

A new year means a brand new series of the only show on telly where you can see an oversized recycling bin performing in a sing-off with an anthropomorphised pile of yarn or a surprisingly flirtatious slab of dessert.

Yes, the fourth season of The Masked Singer is now fully underway.

Viewers have been introduced to all 10 of the weird and wonderful characters hoping to follow in the footsteps of former champions Sausage, Panda and Queen Bee, with football legend Chris Kamara and British music icon Lulu being the first to be sent packing.

But what about the eight characters still in the running?

Well, here are all the fan theories so far about who the celebrities underneath the masks could be…

Knitting

ITV

We’re starting with Knitting because she’s actually the one we’re the most convinced about.

Although the judges originally offered up names like Jane Horrocks, Samantha Barks and AJ Odudu, we’re going to go with our instinct and say we’re pretty sure it’s Claire Richards (aka Claire from Steps) underneath all that wool.

We counted references to two Steps songs in her first appearance, beginning with the solitary magpie in her VT (One For Sorrow) and ending with her comment about “counting 26” (which just happens to be the total of 5, 6, 7 and 8).

Claire Richards
Claire Richards
Karwai Tang via Getty Images

Knitting also told us she was crafty, with Claire previously appearing on a celebrity edition of the Great British Sewing Bee.

And, oh yeah, there’s the fact that Knitting’s voice sounds just like Claire’s.

Clearly we’re not the only ones who think so, either...

🧶 knitting I think is pretty unmistakably Claire Richards, but trying to do a week one pare back of her vocals so I bloody hope that doesn’t send her home as we NEED a big ballad!! I can hear her even in the faux Yorkshire accent! #TheMaskedSinger

— Adam Robson (@adammarkrobson) January 2, 2023

Knitting is one of the most ingenious #MaskedSingerUK costumes yet! First guess: Claire Richards from Steps. Moments where it sounded like her holding back. “Morning” + “present” - she presented SMTV Live. Not sure on other clues but they can sing! @ThisisDavina @MaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/JOeCmJC9ir

— Jon Connell (@jonconnell) January 1, 2023

Not quite sure from the clues, but Knitting's singing voice is giving me Claire Richards. #MaskedSingerUK

— Mark Siddall (@marksiddall84) January 1, 2023

Masked Singer catch up
Knitting is definitely Claire Richards

All the crafty clues are a huge hint, but it's the Magpie gives it away for me, if you know the rhyme

— Ringing in the New Year 🏳️🌈 (he/him) (@MrBell74) January 2, 2023

Claire Richards inside her Knitting costume #TheMaskedSinger pic.twitter.com/QqqBrfu1Of

— Matt (@mattg194) January 2, 2023

…even if the woman herself seems to be trying to throw us off the scent…

Oooh just had a thought knitting =Stacey Solomon!! I know I’ve said her before for sausage 😂 but she is very crafty!

— Claire Richards (@_ClaireRichards) January 1, 2023

Jellyfish

ITV

As soon as we heard Jellyfish sing, we knew her voice sounded familiar, and we think we might have worked out why.

Having now played it back a few times, the aquatic performer’s rendition of Sweet Child O’ Mine puts us in mind of Anastacia (albeit an Anastacia trying to go easy on the Anastacia-isms), and there are quite a few clues to back it up, too.

Jellyfish commented that she’d won a competition in the past, with Anastacia recently coming out on top in the Australian version of The Masked Singer.

She also offered up a riddle about a “funny animation”, and while we don’t recall Anastacia ever lending her voice to a cartoon, Jellyfish could have been referring to the 1997 film Anastasia.

Anastacia
Anastacia
picture alliance via Getty Images

And while the word “me” written in shells left many wondering if there was a famous Michelle under that aquatic costume, it’s worth pointing out that Anastacia is BFFs with Drag Race icon Michelle Visage.

Even the song choice could be a giveaway, as the I’m Outta Love singer performed Sweet Child O Mine on her latest UK tour.

Another popular name in the frame is Amber Riley, based on Jellyfish’s voice and the fact the Glee star previously won another international season of The Masked Singer.

Amber Riley
Amber Riley
Unique Nicole via Getty Images

Here are some of the other theories going round on Twitter right now…

Jellyfish is Amber Riley - I recognise that voice so much!! #maskedsinger

— Hayley Minn (@hayleyminn) January 1, 2023

Jellyfish is giving Amber Riley but she just won the American one??

— harry (@CommeDesHazons) January 2, 2023

Jellyfish is Anastacia I’m telling you NOW #MaskedSinger

— Liam (@LiamLambrini) January 1, 2023

My wife is convinced Jellyfish is Michelle Gayle #MaskedSingerUK

— Sean Goldsmith (@radiogoldsmith) January 1, 2023

Jellyfish is Kelly Rowland.
Michelle Williams link, and Bootylicious music reference.
Although she sounds more like Amber Riley… who just won #MaskedSinger in the US!#MaskedSingerUK

— Daniel Falconer (@DanielJFalconer) January 1, 2023

Watching #maskedsinger late, but Jellyfish is Michelle Gayle, yeah?

— David Whitley (@mrdavidwhitley) January 1, 2023

Jellyfish…the Michelle clue and the competition winner. Could it be Michelle McManus?#MaskedSingerUK

— bollykecks (@kelmonsoon) January 1, 2023

Jellyfish is Nelly Furtado. I said it.#MaskedSinger

— Ranj Singh (@DrRanj) January 1, 2023

Cat & Mouse

Cat and Mouse
Cat and Mouse
ITV

This year saw the introduction of The Masked Singer’s first ever double act in the form of Cat & Mouse.

After the duo’s first performance, some members of the panel were convinced it was Emma Bunton and Jade Jones underneath the masks, especially after a reference to “jade” in their riddle and a line-up of spices in their VT.

For the time being, that’s our leading theory, our only drawback being that we’re not sure ITV would give the answer away in the first episode.

Jade Jones and Emma Bunton at the Brit Awards in 2019
Jade Jones and Emma Bunton at the Brit Awards in 2019
Jeff Spicer via Getty Images

Here’s what else people are saying on Twitter…

Emma Bunton & Jade Jones - My guess for Cat & Mouse #maskedsinger pic.twitter.com/RF0AVuMnHY

— Gracie (@graciebear_69) January 1, 2023

So intriguing to have a duo! I’m guessing Martin & Shirlie Kemp for Cat & Mouse. Martin has been a judge on talent shows (legal clues) and Shirlie was in the Spice Girls video for Mama. @ThisisDavina @MaskedSingerUK #MaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/SrIO7JbmcY

— Jon Connell (@jonconnell) January 1, 2023

Cat & Mouse - Tom Fletcher & Carrie Hope Fletcher #maskedsinger

— ☆ Samantha ☆ (@xSamanthaHx) January 1, 2023

I'm thinking Glynis Barber & Michael Brandon (Dempsey & Makepeace) Cat & Mouse #MaskedSinger pic.twitter.com/PKoJWEUDhr

— DHumph (@danddhumphries) January 2, 2023

Phoenix

ITV

As with Cat & Mouse, the judges’ guess of David Tennant is our current leading theory for Phoenix – although, again, we’re not sure why ITV would put his name out there so early on.

The voice doesn’t sound unlike David’s, and Phoenix is clearly on the tall side, with the actor himself standing at over six feet.

David Tenannt
David Tenannt
David M. Benett via Getty Images

Phoenix commented that they were good at solving mysteries (David, of course, appeared in Broadchurch after leaving Doctor Who), although we’re stumped on what the character’s clue that he’d “been a catchphrase” might refer to, other than his own catchphrase from his time on Doctor Who.

Another popular theory for Phoenix is Ricky Wilson of the Kaiser Chiefs fame, with many claiming the voice sounds like the former Voice coach.

Ricky Wilson
Ricky Wilson
Carla Speight via Getty Images

However, we’ll have to wait for more clues to work out who’s under the fiery guise…

Im with @wossy #Phoenix is #DavidTennant#Catchphase - allonsy pic.twitter.com/XM1HVh2mi8

— Kirsty Price (@kittyprice86) January 2, 2023

i’m pretty sure phoenix is ricky wilson. don’t ask why, i don’t know, but their voices is almost identical #maskedsingeruk pic.twitter.com/ERsypE9mIq

— alex❦ (@luvfionaapple) January 1, 2023

On second listen to Phoenix, I’m hearing Ricky Wilson @Rickontour! One of my favourite singers, he’s been on my #MaskedSingerUK wish list for years. Fantastic vocal and embodies the character so theatrically. A red hot Phoenix has never been so cool! @ThisisDavina @MaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/QbUezt9B0w

— Jon Connell (@jonconnell) January 1, 2023

If Phoenix isn’t Matthew Lewis I’ll eat a random hat #maskedsinger

— Elly McGinn (@ellymcginn) January 1, 2023

No idea who Phoenix is. All I know is that I fancy him whoever he is. Think it's the flame-y trousers... #maskedsinger

— Lauren Harrison-Ford (@LaurenHarry) January 1, 2023

Jacket Potato

ITV

While Jonathan Ross thought it was Shane Richie underneath Jacket Potato’s spud, Twitter seems to think it’s an entirely different Richie altogether.

One popular theory puts Bon Jovi musician Richie Sambora underneath the mask, with many pointing out that the Romeo & Juliet book that Jacket Potato was seen reading sported the band’s logo.

Jacket Potato also boasted of an impressive collection, with Richie apparently having over 130 guitars to his name.

Richie Sambora
Richie Sambora
John Phillips via Getty Images

Not convinced? Let’s hear what viewers on Twitter had to say...

I‘ll eat my words if there’s a slight chance I’m wrong, but I know that voice!

This is 100% RS in UK masked singer, known as Jacket Potato!
Absolutely loved this cover of Viva Las Vegas!

Honestly, it’s so good seeing him happy & healthy lately… and doing fun stuff like this! pic.twitter.com/HZ66nCGA7R

— Jerry Braden (@Jerrybraden92) January 8, 2023

That voice is undeniable even if these clues hadn’t been included. ❤️🗡 pic.twitter.com/CnnIkgEzhu

— Jennifer🌻 (@jennlyn328) January 8, 2023

Ok probably way off but Baked Potato sounds so much like Richie Sambora from Bon Jovi #MaskedSingerUK https://t.co/FoVUzJYA31

— MarkLovesKylie (@Markloveskylie) January 7, 2023

It's 100% Shane Richie @MaskedSingerUK Jacket Potato #MaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/P02CHhP0Ms

— DavyBoyUK (@DavyBoyUK) January 7, 2023

Keep swapping between Vic Reeves & Bob Mortimer in my head! The names that Jacket Potato put in the jars reminded me of Bob’s cat names… Could really hear him! Brilliantly entertaining Saturday night performance - he mashed it up! 🥔 @ThisisDavina @MaskedSingerUK #MaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/lR5bSAjUl7

— Jon Connell (@jonconnell) January 7, 2023

Getting Shaun Ryder vibes from Jacket Potato #MaskedSingerUK @MaskedSingerUK #Gogglebox pic.twitter.com/nxnb0cG1YU

— Kate🌻 (@vaseysvoyages) January 7, 2023

Fawn

ITV

It might seem like an obvious conclusion to come to, but as soon as Fawn mentioned in her clue package that she’s a fan of Maths, our minds immediately went to Carol Vorderman.

Apparently, we weren’t alone in that – and as she began her rendition of the title song from Beauty And The Beast, some viewers reckoned they recognised Vorders’ voice from when she performed on Celebrity Stars In Their Eyes all those years ago.

Carol Vorderman
Carol Vorderman
Ken McKay/ITV/Shutterstock

Here’s the chat over on Twitter...

Fawn is Carol Vorderman. Recognise that voice from Stars In Their Eyes when she was Cher !#MaskedSingerUK | #maskedsinger pic.twitter.com/y9Y6T2QkB5

— Chris Holliday (@Succourer1982) January 7, 2023

#maskedsingeruk okay hear me out when I say Carol Vorderman for Fawn pic.twitter.com/v3t6koKAK7

— Laura (@_sadz95) January 7, 2023

As a huge All Saints fan I’m pretty sure Fawn is Natalie Appleton! The voice sounds like her, Black Coffee, and the ‘sandy’ clue possibly referring to Pure Shores being on ‘The Beach’ soundtrack #maskedsingeruk

— Chloe (@dreamredux) January 7, 2023

Thinking of @takethat's amazing WONDERLAND Tour 💫
with @AllSaintsOffic & reckon #Fawn could be Natalie Appleton @NatAllSaints 🦌🧡
She's the oldest member so not the baby & 'Sandy' on the necklace could be reference to #PureShores 💛
No milk ~ 🎵 Black Coffee🎵#MaskedSingerUK https://t.co/LiJnRGlSZY

— ♍NORMA❤GB🎹⫩💚LFC❤ (@Normsi2) January 9, 2023

I have listened to it like 30 times because that voice was driving me insane and I've worked it out. FAWN IS DELTA GOODREM #TheMaskedSinger

— Dan H (@Daneeeboy) January 7, 2023

Never mind i think on masked singer fawn is helena bonham carter because she was in Alice in wonderland and played Queen of hearts. pic.twitter.com/WLoAm7V5e3

— JaydonEvans 🏳️🌈 (@JaydonEvans10) January 7, 2023

Rubbish

ITV

When viewers first saw Rubbish walking past a selection of bins coloured red, blue, yellow and green, they immediately thought of Marvin Humes from JLS.

One of the bins had “number one” written one it, which could be a nod to JLS’ several chart-toppers, while there was a particular emphasis on green, which was Marvin’s signature colour during his time in the group.

Marvin Humes
Marvin Humes
SOPA Images via Getty Images

Interestingly, others seem convinced from the clues that it’s a snooker player underneath Rubbish’s bin-lid, thanks to the “number one” being on the red bin, and the character playing a triangle at one point.

Let’s see what Twitter has to say...

Rubbish = Marvin? #TheMaskedSinger pic.twitter.com/RzWjr3pRpz

— Minnie Wright (@MinnieWright_) January 7, 2023

Rubbish is Marvin Humes, green in JLS, went solo in his DJ career, chose to sing something completely different to disguise he can actually sing #TheMaskedSinger

— Daisy Rudge (@daisyrudge) January 7, 2023

Rubbish has to be a snooker player - the triangle, the reds and other colours, the 'clearing up'. Steve Davis, Stephen Hendry or Ronnie O'Sullivan?? #MaskedSingerUK

— Ryan (@iam_ryanman) January 7, 2023

Rubbish is a snooker player. Possibly Shaun Murphy. He had a triangle

— Ian Handley (@ianhandley) January 7, 2023

I've watched the clues again today and #Rubbish is 100% Ronnie O'Sullivan. No.1 on red bin and the rubbish was all the colours of snooker balls and the table #MaskedSingerUK

— 𝐍𝐚𝐭 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐫-𝐁𝐨𝐨 (@TheNatster75) January 8, 2023

Pigeon

ITV

Pigeon is definitely one of our favourite characters of the new series – but she’s also one of the hardest to work out.

So far, viewers seem pretty convinced there’s a comedian under the beak, with her comment about being an “old bird” (and the carrots she was seen holding!) putting some in mind of Catherine Tate.

Catherine Tate
Catherine Tate
Jeff Spicer via Getty Images

Hopefully more will be revealed as the weeks go on – but for the time being, here are some more theories from social media...

#TheMaskedSinger pigeon is Catherine Tate. Carrot top=ginger,dressed like an old lady = nan from the Catherine Tate show. Life imitates art= last name Tate= Tate modern gallery

— Debra Martin (@Debs_martin33) January 7, 2023

Agree that Pigeon could be Catherine Tate, one of her characters is an ‘old bird’, Nan. #MaskedSingerUK

— Lisa Allen (@lovelylisaj) January 7, 2023

watching on +1 BUT IF PIGEON IS NOT CATHERINE TATE I’LL EAT MY HAT #MaskedSingerUK

— liv🧚🏻 (@LivvyHammond) January 7, 2023

Catherine Tate or Stacey Dooley is pigeon #maskedsingeruk - carrots suggested ginger hair and their accents fitted 🥕

— carlywhitepants (@carolineplayle) January 7, 2023

I’m getting Mrs Hinch vibes from Pigeon 🤔 She uses the old lady filter on Instagram and the carrots could be a clue to her pet llamas 🥕
It’s that or the GC #TheMaskedSinger #TheMaskedSingerUK

— daisy (@daisyarigrande) January 7, 2023

Rhino

ITV

The second we heard Rhino singing, we were absolutely convinced he was actually former X Factor winner James Arthur, and when he said during his riddle that one of the judges “might find me quite muggy”, we thought that could be a reference to his previous fling with Rita Ora.

However, a quick browse through Twitter shows all of the clues pointing in a very different direction.

Apparently, fans quickly worked out that it was Busted singer Charlie Simpson underneath Rhino’s thick hide.

Charlie Simpson
Charlie Simpson
David M. Benett via Getty Images

Here’s what people are saying online...

Rhino is Charlie Simpson and no one can convince me otherwise. Recognise that voice anywhere! #TheMaskedSinger

— Kimberley Griffin (@makesumfinup) January 7, 2023

Rhino is 10000000% Charlie Simpson!!!! I've listened to his voice for 20 years! Also, Joel is a Busted fan and follows Charlie! I'm so excited by this!!! #TheMaskedSingerUK pic.twitter.com/azn471DRd1

— H A Y L E Y (@HaylStonee) January 7, 2023

Am I reading too much into this, but Rhino from #MaskedSingerUK sounds like Charlie Simpson who has a son called Arlo and did a song called Forty Thieves...? And I wouldn't put it past him to refer to the other Busted boys as 2 bad jokes 😂 pic.twitter.com/6600KJGgyo

— Mrs Van De Clee (@MrsOC6) January 8, 2023

Rhino is 100% Charlie Simpson

“One of you might think I’m a bit muggy”… Jonathan Ross gave Busted mugs when they were on Friday Night with Jonathan Ross#MaskedSingerUK

— Emma (@Kolakube_5) January 7, 2023

If you are needing proof Rhino is Charlie Simpson 👇👇👇👇#TheMaskedSingerUK #maskedsinger #Rhino pic.twitter.com/cSuDXbqH8q

— ◉☠🖤Pammy Sixx🖤☠◉ (@SheBePamella) January 7, 2023

As someone who has seen Charlie Simpson (not in Busted but solo) many many times live it does sound incredibly like him. The only person who I can think of who sounds similar is James Arthur.

— Lea ⭐️⭐️ (@BlueInkRevenge) January 7, 2023

Otter

ITV

We’ve left Otter until last because while the current theory is the most unlikely on our list, it’s also our favourite. Because it involves Kate Bush.

At first, the “Kate Bush on The Masked Singer” theory is an easy one to dismiss. First of all, she’s famously private, and hasn’t done any telly at all for the last 30 years, including when she’s had albums and a live residency to flog, so it’s not likely she’d choose now to don an oversized novelty costume and sing a cover of the Baywatch theme tune for the nation, is it?

Then there’s the fact she’s one of the most iconic British singers of all time, so why would she of all people feel the need to sign up for something like The Masked Singer (no offence, Masked Singer, we love you, never change).

Kate Bush in 2014
Kate Bush in 2014
David M. Benett via Getty Images

But then… you start to read about Otter’s clues. And there’s no denying that they do all point in the same direction. That direction being… up a certain hill…

Can't believe we live in a world where it's entirely possible Kate Bush is on The Masked Singer UK.

I felt a fool suggesting it earlier but now I'm convinced that's her voice and diction..

Plus the last clue about liking to be heard and not seen... Catherine. Bush. pic.twitter.com/Eye6A8YgF0

— SHANE REACTION (@imshanereaction) January 1, 2023

The other clues:

A shamrock... Kate Bush is half Irish.

A vicar... A deal with God.

She's known for her resilience... Like someone who keeps running up a hill?

I can totally see her doing it after seeing how excited and grateful she was to be #1 last year

— SHANE REACTION (@imshanereaction) January 2, 2023

Surely not. But also… maybe?

The Masked Singer airs on Saturday nights on ITV.

Close

What's Hot