The National Newspaper Under Fire For 'Enemies Of Scotland' Front Page

'Scotland deserves a serious independence-supporting newspaper, this isn't it.'

A Scottish newspaper’s headline which appeared to ape a controversial Daily Mail front page following the High Court’s Brexit decision has proved too much even for some members of the SNP.

The National featured mocked up pictures of prime minister Theresa May, Brexit secretary David Davis and Advocate General Lord Keen QC, with the headline “Enemies of the Scottish people!”.

It added: “Forget the judges - it is unacceptable for the UK Government’s lawyer to argue that Scotland’s voice - and a significant part of the Scotland Act - is irrelevant.

Tomorrow @ScotNational Enemies of the Scottish people! Unacceptable for the UK Government lawyer to argue Scotland’s voice is irrelevant pic.twitter.com/COro6atlhS

— The National (@ScotNational) December 6, 2016

The story concerned discussion in the Supreme Court on Tuesday, where the government is currently challenging the court’s ruling that the PM must consult parliament before triggering Article 50.

The National said that Lord Keen, who is acting on behalf of the government, “told the court during the Article 50 case that the Scottish Government’s contention that the Holyrood Parliament needed to consent to Brexit ‘simply does not arise in this appeal’”.

The front page was strikingly similar to one published by the Daily Mail last month criticising the judges behind the High Court decision the government is currently appealing.

This Daily mail's front page was widely criticised
This Daily mail's front page was widely criticised
Daily Mail

And it seems the National’s own version was also too much for some to stomach, with even SNP MP Callum McCaig branding it “inappropriate”.

This was totally inappropriate when it was the Mail's headline. Equally inappropriate form The National. https://t.co/TnfZc1E6sO

— Callum McCaig (@callum_mccaig) December 6, 2016

His tweet was retweeted by Scottish Conservative leader Ruth Davidson.

The front page also attracted ire elsewhere, including from its own members and other supporters of Scottish independence,

@ScotNational this is shit- you guys are better than this

— Janey Godley (@JaneyGodley) December 7, 2016

@ScotNational You'd be well advised to ditch this and have a blank page. I usually like your covers but this is stupid and unhelpful.

— Gary Feeney (@gf1987) December 6, 2016

@ScotNational @pilaraymara Scotland deserves a serious Independence supporting newspaper, this isn't it

— Aιηɗяιύ (@Tawnynoran) December 6, 2016

@ScotNational sorry guys too Daily Mail esk! Please change.

— Graeme Turner 😆 (@gturner1969) December 7, 2016

@ScotNational Terrible front cover. Not only puts off new readers but repels your regulars too. Fail.

— SNPeace❤ (@blair_janey) December 7, 2016

@ScotNational aping the mail, seriously? What the fuck.

— Indy Sparck (@O3_S_Yes) December 6, 2016

@ScotNational not good imho, aping the Mail won't be seen, you've just made a rod for "our" backs!

— Marsi (@Marsi132) December 7, 2016

@ScotNational Disappointing

— ALAN FERNS (@ForeverYES123) December 6, 2016

@ScotNational This is offensive drivel. It horrifies me that you associate yourself with the independence movement.

— Elaine Ferguson (@fergusonelaine) December 6, 2016

@ScotNational ooh that's not a good front page. Bad decision.

— Shell (@Michex69) December 6, 2016

The front page also caught the attention of former justice secretary Michael Gove, who labelled the National the “worst newspaper in the world”:

The #worstnewspaperintheworld shows us all how to elevate debate on the constitution https://t.co/yx6E176GOh

— Michael Gove (@michaelgove) December 6, 2016

Meanwhile, Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale is set to call for the UK to become a federal state in a “new Act of Union”, with Scotland taking control of a number of areas currently covered by EU law.

The Guardian reported that Dugdale is set to call on May to support a new “political settlement” in the wake of Brexit to prevent a split in the UK.

According to the BBC, she is expected to tell London’s Institute for Public Policy Research: “We are now faced with a Tory government in Westminster which looks set to force hard Brexit on the whole of the UK. And an SNP government at Holyrood which wants to exploit the divisions to win independence.

“This is the position that the majority of Scots - the moderate, pro-union Scots and also many former Yes voters - find themselves in.

“More than ever, we have two governing parties in Scotland that are out of step with what the majority of people in Scotland want. The Tories want Scotland in the UK and out of Europe, and the SNP want Scotland in the EU, but out of the UK.

“Continuing to pull our country in each of these directions risks breaking the union once and for all.”

Close

What's Hot